Geno’s Pizza

Reviews

• Josh J.

  star star star star_border star_border 16 July 2026

  We had a coupon for three pizzas at Geno's so we went ahead and gave it shot without even looking at reviews. I was a little worried when I seen then reviews but since it was delivery we'd already committed at that point.
  
  Overall the pizza was average pizza. Nothing real special but not real bad flavor to it. We got two pepperoni pizzas and one sausage pizza for the order. The pepperoni was good but the sausage really didn't have much sausage flavor to it. I'm not a fan of really doughy pizza but it can't be too thin either. All these pizzas had the right amount of dough for me, not too thick and not too thin.
  
  Its hard to find decent pizza that delivers in large tourist towns but Geno's is one of them. I doubt I'd stop in for a slice if i was already out but a solid option if you're already settled in for the night.
  
  P.S. They told us 45 minutes on delivery which I thought there was no way with the traffic so we set a timer. Literally at 44 minutes and 50 seconds the knoxk was at the door.

• Ang K.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 15 July 2026

  DiGiorno is much better than the pizza here. I was hoping the reviews were incorrect, but we chose this as a late night option right next to the lodge we were staying at. Since we could walk there, we decided to order take out. We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, which was $15 almost. For the quality and tastelessness, they are way overpriced. The staff was nice and pizza was done within 10 mins. They seemed to continue getting delivery orders, but not sure how they are still open.

• Ms P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 12 July 2026

  I really try not to leave bad reviews but because we were so disappointed in our pizza I just had to do it. We ordered a $27 large meat special pizza, the amount of toppings were good but the pizza had very little if any sauce and the crust was thicker than usual for a hand tossed pizza. The taste we were expecting was way off and the crust wasn't nice and toasted. Full disclosure they close at midnight we went for a late meal at 11:40 pm so I was thinking perhaps late order means lesser quality food but judging from similar comments my guess this is typical. I would have been better off going to Pizza Hut down the street. Thumbs down for me.

• Hope W.

  star star star star star 9 July 2026

  Very good Italian pizza! Ended up craving Pizza around midnight! I was a little hesitant to order but the prices are well worth it! Authentic Italian pizza! We also used to coupon for a free thing of breadsticks! The garlic butter was delicious! Will be ordering every vacation from now on! Can't forget the website said the wait would be 45 minutes for delivery but I had my pizza within 15 minutes! On a plus side they are also open until 3AM!
  Check your hotel lobby's for coupons!

• Melissa S.

  star star star star star_border 8 July 2026

  This reminds us of old 'Godfathers pizza'.  A thicker crust but flavorful.  Ordered through door dash the service was prompt and the food was still hot when it arrived at our cabin.  We ordered the chef salad and everything in it is so fresh.